Home > Business, Economics, Socialism > Is the rise of technology and the obsolescence of labor a case for public ownership of capital?

Is the rise of technology and the obsolescence of labor a case for public ownership of capital?

Just read this piece about the USPS and it got me thinking. It fits into the bigger narrative that I’ve been assembling about prolonged chronic unemployment; essentially, most of the jobs that have been shed in the last 3 years are never coming back. Now that firms have scaled back their labor forces, they are realizing a number of efficiency gains through the use of technological capital, and they aren’t going to need those old workers ever again.

When automation was first introduced into manufacturing, labor unions had to organize politically in order to maintain “fair” wages for employees who would have otherwise been displaced by the automation. On the margins, firms still benefited from automation, but part of the gains were shared with labor. Today, with the unions eviscerated, and the internet bringing about a new era of labor saving/capital intensive innovation, labor will not receive any of the gains from automation. They will be chronically unemployed and the all of the profits will go to the owners and management.

In the long run, this will decrease demand as wages fall, and should lead to falling prices… “should” being the operative word there. Market inefficiencies will slow price signals and allow the firms to capture extra consumer surplus as real price levels rise due to falling real incomes. How long it will take to reach this new equilibrium is uncertain, and in the meantime, we have a chronically unemployed underclass.

I think of Jonas Salk, who invented a Polio vaccine and gave it to the world for free, rather than make a billion dollars from it. This doesn’t happen anymore. The gains from technology are not shared by society. Capital enjoys the lion’s share, while labor and consumers receive a modest marginal benefit: the option to purchase said technology.

The utopia I imagine is a world where people don’t have to work; robots and artificial intelligence can do it all for us, and society can share in the benefit presented by this automation. The problem is that the emergence of that level of automation will only happen if and when capital invests in it (and the “if” is resoundingly a “yes” because it will reduce variable costs so greatly), and capital will only invest in it because of their profit motive.

“Isn’t it bad for producers when real incomes (and demand) fall? Isn’t it in the economic interests of firms to support a strong middle class consumption base?” Yes, in the long run it is bad for firms, and it is in firms interest to support a strong consumer base; to share the pie. The problem is that “firms” are abstract. Management and ownership is making the decisions, and these decisions are biased towards short term revenue and profit projections. The problems of an eroding consumer base are on the far horizon, and in the meantime, capital can use its political power to make stop-gap solutions to prop up demand, such as expanding the government’s balance sheet, the monetary supply, and/or the lower and middle class’s tax burdens (this is already happening, and has been happening for 30 years [with brief respites here and there in the 90’s], to give you an idea of the time span that it takes for these real income shocks to have an effect). By the time that stagnated or falling real incomes come to have an impact on the firms’ income statements, the current ownership and management is going to be long retired.

The only way to avoid this is for labor and the unemployed to reorganize politically, or for some radical cultural realignment that replaces the motivation from profit with the motivation from compassion (Bill Gates and Warren Buffet are setting an example, but in the grand scheme of things we will need millionaires, as well as billionaires, to change what motivates them).

Categories: Business, Economics, Socialism
  1. No comments yet.
  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: